Previous Entry | Next Entry

Shounen Heroes, Self -Centered?

  • Apr. 4th, 2003 at 11:42 AM
naanima: (Default)
*re-reads last entry* Hmm, this probably explains why I get so easily addicted to shounen crack. I mean it, see, most -true- shounen heroes starts off not really knowing anything, but it's that inner fire to fullfill their dreams, their hopes that attract me to them. Their obnoxious self been a strangely appealing factor as well.

Lets just look at the storylines of my favourite shounen manga; YuYuHakusho, Houshin Engi, Hikaru no Go, HunterxHunter, Bleach, Shaman King, and recently Prince of Tennis (there are more I just can't remember them all). See the common link? It isn't hard, young boys becoming more and more powerful at their chosen sport/game/passion, they go through crap, the mature, yet they can still be a prat at times.

The main leads in the stories can also be considered extremely self-centered. *ducks the flying fruits* Seriously, I love them, but there's no fucking way that people can tell me the protagonists in their respective series are not selfish when it comes to fullfiling their dreams. They don't purposely hurt people, but they do it anyway, and most of them are aware of this, but, up to a point, they can't stop moving forward because of their dream, their ambition. They have to become stronger!

Hmm, that would explain Griffith *mumblestoself*

Comments

ext_73923: (Default)
[identity profile] amei.livejournal.com wrote:
Apr. 4th, 2003 06:54 am (UTC)
Hmmm HxH admittedly, HnG definately, but I'd debate the Houshin Engi one...

Taikoubou is probably the most altruistic protaganist I've come across to date because the way I read it, his dream *was* everyone else's dream. No way he went through all that shit for himself. He would have been just as happy meditating in Kunlun. In the end of book 23, when he finally fufilled the task he was set, well, the last few pages of the manga gave me the feeling he didn't really know what to do with his future, simply because he's lived for everyone else's lives for so long. How it ends with him staring at the sky and all, struck me as lonely and somewhat sad.

Of course it -has- been a long time since I've read Houshin so...

(Shaman King? ambition? er..? Yoh? I have only read like...3 volumes. He's the most ambitionless character I've ever seen...--")
[identity profile] worldserpent.livejournal.com wrote:
Apr. 4th, 2003 02:53 pm (UTC)
Agreed on the Houshin... I found the ending very sad as well.

Re: Shaman King. Yeah, Yoh is the laid back one, although he does want to become SK. It's Ren and Anna who have the ambition, and there's all these other people who are backing Yoh up and have their hopes riding on his success, and the need to prevent Hao from taking ultimate power that make him go forward.

HXH: definitely. Gon and Killua have no mission (talk about immorality: Killua's a stone cold killer). It's only Kurapika that does have a goal. I have to admit this has been making HXH very boring for the past few vols.
[identity profile] naanima.livejournal.com wrote:
Apr. 5th, 2003 07:41 am (UTC)
No, no, both of you are right on Houshin, my mistake there. I think the obnoxious/idiotic character type (or pretending to be on the surface)is forever connected with the self-centered type in my brain. I'll think more before I type next time, it's just that all all my fav shounen series decided to pop up at the same time an dI just blah'd without brain connecting^^;; Forgive me.

But yes, the ending to HE was very sad, yet extremely fitting. I've a whole list of reasons as to why it's the right ending, and I'll probly go into much depth when I can think straight. But one of them is definitely what Amei said, but I also think it relate back to the whole reason why Taikobou started the whole thing in the first place. No interference by the greater powers indeed. And then, there's the whole temptation of wanting to change the course of history now that he has the power, not that I'm saying he would, but it's there nonetheless, and Taikoubou (or would that be Fukki?) is wise enough to realise there will be times that he would be tempted if he were to involve himself with the workings of the worlds. But it's sad, and I just want to give him the biggest hug ever *sigh*

As for SK, well, Charmian pretty much said everyting I wanted to say, so, I'll just nod and agree ^^
[identity profile] perseid.livejournal.com wrote:
Apr. 4th, 2003 05:08 pm (UTC)
obnoxious protagonists
I should reaaally start on Houshin no Engi - I know you've explained the plot to me multiple times, but for some strange reason I can never hold on to the story. o__O

I love more than 3/4s of the manga and anime that you've listed - I've always been a sucker for that kind of thing, protagonists growing stronger and more mature through the course of the story. And yes, it is the obnoxious factor that makes them so appealing. I'd prefer that rather than snivelling kids who sit in a corner and sulk because they're unwilling to do something about their hangups.

Hmm, I'd contend that it's possible to be self-centered about their dreams, but aware of how it affects others around them. Because in the end, half of them do what they do because they are driven by other ppl's needs or situations.

Except Griffith, of course. ^^

PerSeiD
[identity profile] naanima.livejournal.com wrote:
Apr. 5th, 2003 07:49 am (UTC)
Re: obnoxious protagonists
Yes, you should go and read Houshin like righ tnow. It's wonderful shounen crack, and Amei and Charmian is doing a muhc better job of explaining things then I ever did ^^;;;

I'd prefer that rather than snivelling kids who sit in a corner and sulk because they're unwilling to do something about their hangups.

Gods, hands up who want to throttle Shinji! But yes, that's one aspect I love about most shounen heroes. It's extremely important that they take their destiny into their own hands, not just because they were forced into it. There MUST be a choice.

Hmm, I'd contend that it's possible to be self-centered about their dreams, but aware of how it affects others around them. Because in the end, half of them do what they do because they are driven by other ppl's needs or situations.

Exactly. Damn it, I just can't seem to say what's in my head... well, actually what's in my head just doesn't want to form into coherent words. But you're right, they are AWARE of the harm they cause to others (most of the time) through certain actions, but they go and do it anyways, not because they want to hurt others but because they've weighed the options in their heads and the best route usually goes hand in hand with their dreams. Hmm, me thinks me did not explain it to the best.

Oh well, I'll eventually get it right.

Profile

naanima: (Default)
[personal profile] naanima
witty, somehow

Latest Month

October 2009
S M T W T F S
    123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

Tags

Powered by Dreamwidth Studios
Designed by [personal profile] chasethestars